Home Help Search Login Register

Brass-Forum.co.ukTubasInstruments - Tubas › How do I oil a rotary valve system?

Pages: 1
Send Topic Print
How do I oil a rotary valve system? (Read 2051 times)
kievins
Deputy
*
Offline

Yes, I am a brass
player!

Posts: 1

How do I oil a rotary valve system?
01/24/08 at 16:59:14
 
I have recently bought a tuba with a rotary valve system, and I was wondering, how do I oil it? I wasn't clever enough to ask when I bought it, and noone I know knows either.
Thanks
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
windshieldbug
Rank & File
**
Offline

A conductor's value
is it's resistance.
And tempo!

Posts: 119

Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #1 - 01/24/08 at 18:22:04
 
Turn the horn over on it's back, remove the back rotor caps, and put a tiny amount in the center of the backing plate, where you see the bottom of the valve sticking through the center of the plate.  Replace the covers, and turn the horn back over.  I also just a drop or two on the top, where the valve stem protrudes below the actuating cap

For a more thorough job, remove the valve slides, and squirting a little oil into the slide, re-inserting it, and do the proper "spin" while working the valve back and forth.  Also putting oil directly into the mouthpipe will keep everything (tubing and all) well coated.

It should be noted that unlike piston valves, the rotors wear on the top and bottom where they stick through the casing and plate.  This is where the sealing takes place, not necessarily at the big sides of the valve.  Usually, they also need nowhere NEAR the oiling required for piston valves, and regular playing is often sufficient.

At least it was as I was dodging the odd dinosaur...  Wink
Back to top
 
 
WWW   IP Logged
ekdavies
Assistant Principal
***
Offline

Amateur horn player

Posts: 287
Evesham, Worcs
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #2 - 01/24/08 at 18:24:57
 
There are several lubrications required.

1.  The mechanism (especially if a mechanical link) should be oiled with a thick oil.  Some people use car engine oil but it need not be quite that thick!  Anything much thinner and the links will rattle and sometimes be sticky.  Take the links apart to oil a ball and socket as well as a pin joint.  Most new instruments do not have the links adequately lubricated - if at all.

2.  The bottom of the valve (some people call this the capston) needs to run smoothly against the valve casing.  This requires some relatively thin oil.  If you unscrew the cap you can gain access to the top bearing which also needs a single drop of thin oil.

In general, you should not squirt or drop oil down the slides.  This has a tendency to was any slide grease into the valve which will make the valve stick - for which the only solution is to take the valve apart and putting it back together takes some skill (ie a technician).  The condensation in the valve is normally sufficient to keep the valve moving and sealing.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
iiipopes
Maestro
*****
Offline



Posts: 4057

Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #3 - 01/24/08 at 22:35:05
 
Sewing machine oil works great on rotor spindles. That's what I use, as it was recommended to me by Roger Lewis, who is the M-W/Melton distributor for the USA and had decades of experience. A 4-ounce bottle is less than USA$2.00, as opposed to the boutique oils that charge several dollars/pounds for a one-ounce bottle.

For the rest of the rotor linkage, I was recommended to use a light machine oil called 3-In-1 oil, which I don't know if there is a UK version or not. Also much cheaper by comparison to volume.

Occasionally I'll put regular piston valve oil down the lead pipe to clear gunk. But as stated above, I don't put it down the individual valve slides for that very reason: the oil can dissolve the slide grease into gunk and foul the rotors.
Back to top
 
 

Besson BBb 3-v comp
Miraphone 186 detachable - both bells
Fanned fret electric & bass guitars
If you ever see a King Super 20 trumpet
in silverplate, serial #330XXX,
please advise
  IP Logged
windshieldbug
Rank & File
**
Offline

A conductor's value
is it's resistance.
And tempo!

Posts: 119

Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #4 - 01/24/08 at 23:18:32
 
windshieldbug wrote on 01/24/08 at 18:22:04:
squirt a little oil into the slide, re-insert it, and do the proper "spin" while working the valve back and forth


Thus put the oil into the removed slide, not the open valve tubing, and replacing the slide back in fully before turning the horn should avoid said problem.
Back to top
 
 
WWW   IP Logged
iiipopes
Maestro
*****
Offline



Posts: 4057

Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #5 - 01/25/08 at 14:19:54
 
With due respect, especially on the first valve of a conventional 4-valve rotary tuba, you pull  for intonation. Others have a kicker for the 2nd valve slide as well. As you pull out, you expose the grease on the internal surfaces of the valve tubing. This gives the residue of the valve oil a chance to drip off the interior of the slide, wash through the grease, and the mess gets pushed down towards the rotor when you push the slide back in.

Been there, done that, had to use an old t-shirt to clean the gunk out of the first valve slide, plus a trip to the tech to have the rotor pulled and the casing cleaned.
Back to top
 
 

Besson BBb 3-v comp
Miraphone 186 detachable - both bells
Fanned fret electric & bass guitars
If you ever see a King Super 20 trumpet
in silverplate, serial #330XXX,
please advise
  IP Logged
windshieldbug
Rank & File
**
Offline

A conductor's value
is it's resistance.
And tempo!

Posts: 119

Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #6 - 01/25/08 at 15:40:55
 
With due respect, that exact circumstance could also happen with oil put on the bearining surfaces or in the mouthpipe.  Oil, going down to one micron, could end up anywhere.  When I'm done playing, I push ALL the slides fully in, partially for that reason.
Back to top
 
 
WWW   IP Logged
iiipopes
Maestro
*****
Offline



Posts: 4057

Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #7 - 01/25/08 at 19:50:46
 
Where reasonable people may differ, although I would submit that most players pull at least the 1st valve slide at certain times for tuning, depending on the partials and the personality of the individual instrument, and a sizeable contingent of rotary players have one or more of the other slides pulled on a more or less permanent basis at some point for tuning, such as pulling 3 for 23 combinations to be in tune, and 4 for lower notes.
Back to top
 
 

Besson BBb 3-v comp
Miraphone 186 detachable - both bells
Fanned fret electric & bass guitars
If you ever see a King Super 20 trumpet
in silverplate, serial #330XXX,
please advise
  IP Logged
ekdavies
Assistant Principal
***
Offline

Amateur horn player

Posts: 287
Evesham, Worcs
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #8 - 02/06/08 at 23:18:12
 
I suspect we've all put oil down the tube when the valve is still sticky after oiling the bearings and links.  However, for the reasons posted above this approach is risky but worth a try when the alternative is abandoning the rehearsal or taking the valve apart.  Once you've taken the valve apart and cleaned it, if the oiled rotor does not freely and smoothly rotate then it needs specialist attention because the tolerances are probably too tight.  Any-one who has successfully reassembled a rotary valve knows that taking it apart is the easy bit, aligning it (and the cap) and ensuring that it neither too far in nor too far our is the tricky bit.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
iiipopes
Maestro
*****
Offline



Posts: 4057

Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #9 - 02/07/08 at 04:03:53
 
Indeed. As much as I tinker with other musical instruments, especially guitars and basses, and have even worked on pipe organs, I leave the brass work to my tech.
Back to top
 
 

Besson BBb 3-v comp
Miraphone 186 detachable - both bells
Fanned fret electric & bass guitars
If you ever see a King Super 20 trumpet
in silverplate, serial #330XXX,
please advise
  IP Logged
Jonathantuba
Rank & File
**
Offline

I am a Tuba Player

Posts: 59

Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #10 - 02/11/08 at 01:08:12
 
I sometime stand my tubas on their bell vertical, pull out the main tuning slide and VERY CAREFULLY drop oil down the centre (so it does not hit the side walls) while moving the valves with my other hand.  I find this the most effective way of oiling the inside of the rotors and in 3 years I have never had trouble with slide grease getting into the rotors.

I like the system on my Mel Culbertson Neptune which has reversed slides (the slide goes over, rather than inside the fixed tubing) which means no risk of slide grease getting washed into the valves.  I wonder why other tubas to not have this system?
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
iiipopes
Maestro
*****
Offline



Posts: 4057

Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #11 - 02/11/08 at 02:51:54
 
Jonathantuba, you have a point about how you carefully drip the oil in. Moreover, when you reassemble the horn to playing position, the main valve slide is below the valves, so the slide grease doesn't work its way back up into the valves.

Over/Under -- you're right. It would be a better system. Similar to trumpet slides now being over/under as well so the saddles or rings can be attached to them for intonation adjustment.

Why aren't they all like that? Tradition. Tuba players and makers tend to be a conservative lot. The basic design of a BBb rotary tuba has not changed significantly since it was first developed. Ever. There are minor variances in the wrap, bell diameter, bore diameter, and whether the main tuning slide is horizontal or vertical, but for the most part they are indistinguishable at a glance. So something like that is not going to change overnight.
Back to top
 
 

Besson BBb 3-v comp
Miraphone 186 detachable - both bells
Fanned fret electric & bass guitars
If you ever see a King Super 20 trumpet
in silverplate, serial #330XXX,
please advise
  IP Logged
Stewart Lewins
Principal
*****
Offline



Posts: 753
Reading, England
Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #12 - 03/02/08 at 01:24:13
 
I've put oil in the valve slides of Bb/F trombones many, many times and never had problems.
Back to top
 
 
hank_sinatra   IP Logged
peter birch
Assistant Principal
***
Offline

Yes, I am a brass
player!

Posts: 177
ne england
Gender: male
Re: How do I oil a rotary valve system?
Reply #13 - 03/28/08 at 12:12:06
 
Harvey Phillips and William Winkle's "Art of Tuba and Euphonium" has an excellent chapter on the care and maintenance of rotary valves
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Pages: 1
Send Topic Print



Brass-Forum.co.uk » Powered by YaBB 2.2.1!
YaBB © 2000-2008. All Rights Reserved.


©2008 Brass-Forum

Websites by Adrian Horn - Brass-Forum.co.uk |SaleBrass.co.uk | HuwMorgan.net